If you are having issues with TRUE custom skates fitting you properly you will likely have worse problems with Bauer customs.
TRUE builds their skates from the inside out and the materials they use are extremely thermoformable. This allows them to adapt to your foot much better than the materials used by other manufacturers. I have found that people who needed to have a skate heavily modified, punched, foams added, basically altering most of the fit to accommodate their foot type have issues with custom Bauer and CCM skates and usually end up in TRUE customs.
Feet going numb can be due to a number of issues. Lacing the skate overly tight, lack of skate volume, incorrect skate length, skate tongue putting pressure on the forefoot. Most of these issues can be addressed by a good pro shop.
Did TRUE remake your second pair or did they make adjustments to the first pair and then send them back?
What shop did you scan? How have they tried to rectify fitment issues?