I've had the same pair of Bauer Supreme TotalOne NXGs for 10 years now and it's time to lay them to rest. I love them and how they feel and want to buy as similar to them as I can. I unfortunately don't live anywhere close to a hockey shop, so I'll have to be ordering gloves online to try.
On Reddit, someone suggested checking out True Catalysts and the 2S Pro gloves, but I also wanted to ask here if anyone had any other recommendations worth trying.