I personally like the look of the profile ii compared to the flatter 580s, but that's all personal preference. I tried the new Bauer titanium facemask iii , but didn't like how it doesn't wrap the bottom of the chin and leaves that area exposed from a protection standpoint. Also agree with the poster who said the weight difference is more noticeable in hand than when wearing it. Maybe I'm just used to the old style, but I think I'm going to grab a profile ii while they're marked down.