I have this same issue; I found Jetspeeds fit the best... but I use Bauer and keep the middle eyes just snug so that I don't have pain on the top of the foot.
Anyone else notice the style on the young guns (bedard, celibrini) in the league with the big helmet tilt? How does a duster like me achieve this look to look cool on Tuesday nights in my beer league, pinch the helmet, get a too small fit?