I'm actually reviewing the Nike 0004, which is the exact same helmet as the Bauer 4000, minus the logos. Fit- First off, I have a pretty darn big head. I've had a hard time fitting into many of the new helmets, such as the Itech HC 100 and CCM 1052. With those helmets, its more the shape of the helmet that doesn't work with my head, not the size. I got the 0004 in a XL and even though I have it on the smallest setting, it fits me perfectly. Its the best fitting helmet that I've ever worn, but obviously it won't fit every head type. 9.5/10 Protection- I've always felt that this helmet has pretty good protection, but not great. I tend to get hit a lot and I've had some pretty big hits on my head while wearing this helmet. I had two very mild concussions while wearing this helmet, but I don't think any helmet (minus the Carbster) would prevent that. Sometimes if I get hit in the head hard, I'll get a little big of a headache. I sort of question the protection in the helmet with just the thin layers of foam. 6/10 Weight- Very, very light, even with a cage straped on. No complaints at all. 10/10 Durability- Had it for over two full seasons. I'm usually on the ice around 5-10 hours a week. Its held up great. A few scratches here and there, but no cracks or anything. 10/10 Intangibles- I've been pretty limited to helmets because of the fitting issue. Its served its purpose well. I like it. Its a classic looking helmet, and its easily adjustable. I don't mind the one tool adjustment at all, I think its more stable than the 5000's clips. Conclusion- Its a great helmet for most levels of play. Its light, it has a great fit, and its durable. I've had it for two years and am going to replace it soon. Unless the new Bauer 8000 will fit my noggin, I'll be buying another one of these shortly. I'd suggest this helmet to most anyone, but if you've had head problems in the past, or play in an overly physical league, I'd probably get something more protective. Overall I give this helmet a 8.5/10.