Mission Carbster Helmet Black Size Large Itech half-shield Used for beer league Fit-I found it a little too tight with the liner in so I removed it. It was squeezing my head and giving me a headache. (yes, I ordered the right size) With the liner removed it sat too low on my forehead so I duct taped a piece of padding inside to hold it up off my forehead. All good. 8/10 Protection-Second to none though I worry about protection from concussions with the liner removed as the padding inside is quite firm. I haven't taken any hard blows to the head yet so I don't know. Pucks & sticks deflect off with little more than a scuff or paint chip. 10/10 Weight-A little heavy but hardly noticeable. 9/10 Durability-Like I said above-it takes a beating with no problem. After nearly two years of use people are still asking me if I got a new helmet. Other than a few paint chips it's still shiny. The only problem I've had with it is that the plastic tabs that hold the liner in broke off after only a few times removing/reinstalling. Like I said, I don't use the liner but if I did obviously this would be a problem 5/10 Intangibles-Like I said above-"nearly two years of use". Yeah, I like it. I tend to gravitate towards unusual gear so the odd look is right up my alley B) 10/10 Conclusion-Excellent helmet that never took off due to the high price and goofy look. It was a steal at $30 clearance price. Average rating 8.4/10