Jump to content
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Slate Blackcurrant Watermelon Strawberry Orange Banana Apple Emerald Chocolate Marble
Sign in to follow this  
Torikkun

Table(s) of All MSH ProSharp Reviews

Recommended Posts

Hey Everyone! I organized all the reviews into a table with the links to each person's post. This way, you can easily see how they transitioned through each profile and read through the review chronologically. It was a little difficult to organize because people were usually getting back several runners in batches, but I tried my best. I wanted to share a direct link to the spreadsheet, but wasn't sure how to do that anonymously, so the data has just been pasted in several posts below.

I have it sorted via the following ways: 1) Username, 2) Runner Size, and 3) Hollow. I wanted to somehow sort by hockey experience as well, but it was difficult to standardize everyone's experience. I just took snippets from the info they provided.

Table Legend

  • Highlighted in green are the final profiles the user decided on.
  • In yellow are either their 2nd place picks, ties for 1st/2nd place, or the profile that they liked out of the ones they tried, but it didn't seem like they finished their profiling "journey".
  • (Personally, I never finished mine because I kept getting injured on/off for the whole year, then I found I needed new skates, and then COVID happened.)

My Observations

  • It took people an average of +4 profiles from stock (so technically 5 total) to figure out which one they liked.
  • Of the 7 users who distinctly stated their favorite profile, 6/7 picked a Quad. 2/7 picked a Triple (Hudson V).
  • Of the ones users would have been happy with (yellow) if they hadn't tried out their favorite profile, most were tied on triples and quads. This leads me to believe that the majority of people would benefit from trying out a triple or quad profile, but in this region, the differences start to become smaller, so you get into diminishing returns.
  • Honorable Mention: @gevorkya's journey was interesting to read because they ended up trying several different hollows on the same profile to land on their favorite. (Read their Quad 1 review for reference.)

Hopefully this helps people out a bit if they want to try out profiling! Last I checked, most places didn't offer profiles, but it seems like even big retailers are starting to offer it.

Edit//Link to Excel version of spreadsheet.

Edited by Torikkun
18Jul21 - Added a downloadable Excel version of table.
  • Like 2

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorted by Username

User Steel Runner Size Hollow Experience Profile 1 (Control) Profile 2 Profile 3 Profile 4 Profile 5 Profile 6
Aggie Step 272 100/50 FBV Started roller in college in 1998; Switch to ice in 2005 Single - 10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
cjpritch Bauer LS4 306 1/2" Started in 4th grade thru high school. 2 yr break in college. Single - 11' Double - 9'-10'        
cjv31 Tydan 280 1/2" Started at 7; Switched to goalie at 13 for 30 yrs; Player for 4 yrs (?) Single - 9' Double - 9'-10'        
clarkiestooth Tydan 263 3/4" Junior A, 4 yr NCAA, Currently 56 yo Self Custom Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
Dave P Tydan 280 ? Skating since forever Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Double - 9.5'-10.5'
+ Forward Pitch
     
Deke Step ? 90/75 FBV Started in high school; 40+ yrs N/A Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
Double - 10'-20'    
dkmiller3356 Step 272 100/50 FBV Started at 34; 17 years Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
     
gevorkya Step Black 272 1/2" Started at 18; 20+ yrs Single - 9' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0 - 5/8" ROH
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
jdilley Bauer LS3
Tydan
288 100/50 FBV Play from 10-17yo; Restarted in 2010 Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
jpeaslee Step Black 288 7/8" Inline growing up, 1.5 years on ice Single - 11' Double - 9'-10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
 
kpyoung ? ? ? Skating since forever N/A Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
krp2115 Step Black ? 90/75 FBV Started skating at 4/5; Started hockey at 7 N/A Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
kvm Step Black 280 3/4" Play 8-15yo; 15 yrs as adult N/A Quad 2
7'-10'-13'-16'
       
marka Step 263 5/8" Fire Started at 46 in 2015/2016 Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10'
+1/2deg Pitch
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
 
McJesus ? ? 7/8" 20 yrs Single - 12' Single - 14' Double - 10'-20'      
mojo122 Bauer LS5 254 90/50 FBV Played high school + college; 40+ years Single - 10' Triple - Glide 60
(11'-50mm-11')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20'
)
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Double - 10'-20'  
pgeorgan ? 254 ? ? Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Goalie Sam Sr
10'-50mm-27'
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
     
SabbyP Tydan 271 5/8" Started at 14; 10 yr break; Started again at 39 1.5 yrs ago Double - 9'-10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
static86 Step 272 3/4" Started in 20s; 10 yrs Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
 
stick9 Step
Tydan
246 3/4" C level men's league Single - 10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
tcraig Bauer LS4 280 3/4" Started at 5; high school, Jr C, B; 10 yr break; Restarted 2 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
Torikkun Step 220 3/4" 3 yrs Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
tpratt27 Bauer LS3 272 3/4" Started at 4; ACHA in college Single - 9'          
Vulcan7905 Tydan 280 90/75 FBV 3 yrs as child; Restarted at 27 Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
   
Wolfpack_1986 Tydan 238 90/75 FBV Started in college 12 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
   
yan Mission Pitch 263 7/16" Pond hockey growing up; 10 yrs Single - 9' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
yipperzz CCM SB 4.0 247 90/1 FBV Roller for 25 yrs; Ice for 20 yrs Double - 8'-12'
Forward Pitch
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
       

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorted by Runner Size

User Steel Runner Size Hollow Experience Profile 1 (Control) Profile 2 Profile 3 Profile 4 Profile 5 Profile 6
Torikkun Step 220 3/4" 3 yrs Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
Wolfpack_1986 Tydan 238 90/75 FBV Started in college 12 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
   
stick9 Step
Tydan
246 3/4" C level men's league Single - 10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
yipperzz CCM SB 4.0 247 90/1 FBV Roller for 25 yrs; Ice for 20 yrs Double - 8'-12'
Forward Pitch
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
       
mojo122 Bauer LS5 254 90/50 FBV Played high school + college; 40+ years Single - 10' Triple - Glide 60
(11'-50mm-11')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20'
)
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Double - 10'-20'  
pgeorgan ? 254 ? ? Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Goalie Sam Sr
10'-50mm-27'
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
     
clarkiestooth Tydan 263 3/4" Junior A, 4 yr NCAA, Currently 56 yo Self Custom Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
marka Step 263 5/8" Fire Started at 46 in 2015/2016 Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10'
+1/2deg Pitch
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
 
yan Mission Pitch 263 7/16" Pond hockey growing up; 10 yrs Single - 9' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
SabbyP Tydan 271 5/8" Started at 14; 10 yr break; Started again at 39 1.5 yrs ago Double - 9'-10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
Aggie Step 272 100/50 FBV Started roller in college in 1998; Switch to ice in 2005 Single - 10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
dkmiller3356 Step 272 100/50 FBV Started at 34; 17 years Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
     
gevorkya Step Black 272 1/2" Started at 18; 20+ yrs Single - 9' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0 - 5/8" ROH
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
static86 Step 272 3/4" Started in 20s; 10 yrs Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
 
tpratt27 Bauer LS3 272 3/4" Started at 4; ACHA in college Single - 9'          
cjv31 Tydan 280 1/2" Started at 7; Switched to goalie at 13 for 30 yrs; Player for 4 yrs (?) Single - 9' Double - 9'-10'        
Dave P Tydan 280 ? Skating since forever Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Double - 9.5'-10.5'
+ Forward Pitch
     
kvm Step Black 280 3/4" Play 8-15yo; 15 yrs as adult N/A Quad 2
7'-10'-13'-16'
       
tcraig Bauer LS4 280 3/4" Started at 5; high school, Jr C, B; 10 yr break; Restarted 2 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
Vulcan7905 Tydan 280 90/75 FBV 3 yrs as child; Restarted at 27 Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
   
jdilley Bauer LS3
Tydan
288 100/50 FBV Play from 10-17yo; Restarted in 2010 Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
jpeaslee Step Black 288 7/8" Inline growing up, 1.5 years on ice Single - 11' Double - 9'-10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
 
cjpritch Bauer LS4 306 1/2" Started in 4th grade thru high school. 2 yr break in college. Single - 11' Double - 9'-10'        
Deke Step ? 90/75 FBV Started in high school; 40+ yrs N/A Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
Double - 10'-20'    
kpyoung ? ? ? Skating since forever N/A Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
krp2115 Step Black ? 90/75 FBV Started skating at 4/5; Started hockey at 7 N/A Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
McJesus ? ? 7/8" 20 yrs Single - 12' Single - 14' Double - 10'-20'      

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Sorted by Hollow

(ROH grouped together, and FBV grouped together) (Then sorted by bite to more glide)

User Steel Runner Size Hollow Experience Profile 1 (Control) Profile 2 Profile 3 Profile 4 Profile 5 Profile 6
pgeorgan ? 254 ? ? Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Goalie Sam Sr
10'-50mm-27'
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
     
Dave P Tydan 280 ? Skating since forever Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Double - 9.5'-10.5'
+ Forward Pitch
     
kpyoung ? ? ? Skating since forever N/A Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
gevorkya Step Black 272 1/2" Started at 18; 20+ yrs Single - 9' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0 - 5/8" ROH
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
cjv31 Tydan 280 1/2" Started at 7; Switched to goalie at 13 for 30 yrs; Player for 4 yrs (?) Single - 9' Double - 9'-10'        
cjpritch Bauer LS4 306 1/2" Started in 4th grade thru high school. 2 yr break in college. Single - 11' Double - 9'-10'        
SabbyP Tydan 271 5/8" Started at 14; 10 yr break; Started again at 39 1.5 yrs ago Double - 9'-10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
marka Step 263 5/8" Fire Started at 46 in 2015/2016 Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10'
+1/2deg Pitch
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
 
Torikkun Step 220 3/4" 3 yrs Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
stick9 Step
Tydan
246 3/4" C level men's league Single - 10' Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
clarkiestooth Tydan 263 3/4" Junior A, 4 yr NCAA, Currently 56 yo Self Custom Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
static86 Step 272 3/4" Started in 20s; 10 yrs Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
 
tpratt27 Bauer LS3 272 3/4" Started at 4; ACHA in college Single - 9'          
kvm Step Black 280 3/4" Play 8-15yo; 15 yrs as adult N/A Quad 2
7'-10'-13'-16'
       
tcraig Bauer LS4 280 3/4" Started at 5; high school, Jr C, B; 10 yr break; Restarted 2 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
     
yan Mission Pitch 263 7/16" Pond hockey growing up; 10 yrs Single - 9' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Double - 9'-10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
jpeaslee Step Black 288 7/8" Inline growing up, 1.5 years on ice Single - 11' Double - 9'-10' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
 
McJesus ? ? 7/8" 20 yrs Single - 12' Single - 14' Double - 10'-20'      
Aggie Step 272 100/50 FBV Started roller in college in 1998; Switch to ice in 2005 Single - 10' Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
 
dkmiller3356 Step 272 100/50 FBV Started at 34; 17 years Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
     
jdilley Bauer LS3
Tydan
288 100/50 FBV Play from 10-17yo; Restarted in 2010 Single - 10' Double - 9'-10'        
Wolfpack_1986 Tydan 238 90/75 FBV Started in college 12 yrs ago Single - 10' Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Triple - Hudson V/5
(9'-50mm-10.5')
   
Vulcan7905 Tydan 280 90/75 FBV 3 yrs as child; Restarted at 27 Single - 10' Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
   
Deke Step ? 90/75 FBV Started in high school; 40+ yrs N/A Quad 1
(6'-9'-12'-15')
Quad 2
(7'-10'-13'-16')
Double - 10'-20'    
krp2115 Step Black ? 90/75 FBV Started skating at 4/5; Started hockey at 7 N/A Double - 10'-20' Triple - Zuperior M
(6'-13'-20')
     
mojo122 Bauer LS5 254 90/50 FBV Played high school + college; 40+ years Single - 10' Triple - Glide 60
(11'-50mm-11')
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20'
)
Quad 0
(6'-9'-11'-13')
Double - 10'-20'  
yipperzz CCM SB 4.0 247 90/1 FBV Roller for 25 yrs; Ice for 20 yrs Double - 8'-12'
Forward Pitch
Triple - Zuperior S
(6'-12'-20')
       

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Howdy,

Very cool!

FWIW though, I ended up back on the Zuperior S.  My recollection is that while I liked the 50-flat (Hudson?), I started having some knee pain and though it might be related.  Not sure if it was or wasn't in the end, but I've stayed with the Zuperior S regardless.

Mark

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...